Every extra split you try is another chance to find a pattern that is just noise. The 95% range shows how wide that
noise is: if two groups' ranges overlap heavily, the difference is not evidence yet. Pick ONE filter before looking and
check it on trades that settle after you chose it. Backfilled trades carry the Simulator Trend reading only
(BTC and breadth cannot be recovered), so BTC and breadth splits ignore them.
Single-reading filters (starting points, not tuned)
LONG: Simulator Trend ON [sim_trend_on = true]
| Group | Trades | Win rate | 95% range | Net P&L | Avg P&L |
|---|
| All (with readings) | 1167 | 22.6% | 20–25% | -$6,994.76 | -$5.99 |
| KEPT by the filter | 490 | 16.5% | 14–20% | -$3,741.53 | -$7.64 |
| BLOCKED by the filter | 677 | 27.0% | 24–30% | -$3,253.23 | -$4.81 |
153 trades lack a reading this filter needs and are left out.
Win rate kept vs blocked: -10.5 points. The blocked trades made -$3,253.23 in total.
LONG: BTC 4h bullish [btc_trend_4h = bullish]
| Group | Trades | Win rate | 95% range | Net P&L | Avg P&L |
|---|
| All (with readings) | 1320 | 24.8% | 23–27% | -$7,006.14 | -$5.31 |
| KEPT by the filter | 450 | 15.8% | 13–19% | -$3,560.05 | -$7.91 |
| BLOCKED by the filter | 870 | 29.4% | 26–33% | -$3,446.09 | -$3.96 |
Win rate kept vs blocked: -13.6 points. The blocked trades made -$3,446.09 in total.
LONG: BTC trending (not chop) [btc_regime_trending = true]
| Group | Trades | Win rate | 95% range | Net P&L | Avg P&L |
|---|
| All (with readings) | 1320 | 24.8% | 23–27% | -$7,006.14 | -$5.31 |
| KEPT by the filter | 1121 | 24.6% | 22–27% | -$6,041.96 | -$5.39 |
| BLOCKED by the filter | 199 | 25.6% | 20–32% | -$964.18 | -$4.85 |
Win rate kept vs blocked: -1.0 points. The blocked trades made -$964.18 in total.
LONG: Breadth 50%+ up [breadth_24h_pct >= 50]
| Group | Trades | Win rate | 95% range | Net P&L | Avg P&L |
|---|
| All (with readings) | 1320 | 24.8% | 23–27% | -$7,006.14 | -$5.31 |
| KEPT by the filter | 614 | 19.7% | 17–23% | -$4,062.40 | -$6.62 |
| BLOCKED by the filter | 706 | 29.2% | 26–33% | -$2,943.74 | -$4.17 |
Win rate kept vs blocked: -9.5 points. The blocked trades made -$2,943.74 in total.
SHORT: Simulator Trend OFF [sim_trend_on = false]
| Group | Trades | Win rate | 95% range | Net P&L | Avg P&L |
|---|
| All (with readings) | 3136 | 49.2% | 47–51% | +$7,657.45 | +$2.44 |
| KEPT by the filter | 2114 | 41.7% | 40–44% | +$363.20 | +$0.17 |
| BLOCKED by the filter | 1022 | 64.7% | 62–68% | +$7,294.25 | +$7.14 |
Win rate kept vs blocked: -23.0 points. The blocked trades made +$7,294.25 in total.
SHORT: BTC 4h bearish [btc_trend_4h = bearish]
| Group | Trades | Win rate | 95% range | Net P&L | Avg P&L |
|---|
| All (with readings) | 3136 | 49.2% | 47–51% | +$7,657.45 | +$2.44 |
| KEPT by the filter | 2492 | 46.1% | 44–48% | +$3,818.64 | +$1.53 |
| BLOCKED by the filter | 644 | 61.0% | 57–65% | +$3,838.81 | +$5.96 |
Win rate kept vs blocked: -14.9 points. The blocked trades made +$3,838.81 in total.
SHORT: BTC trending (not chop) [btc_regime_trending = true]
| Group | Trades | Win rate | 95% range | Net P&L | Avg P&L |
|---|
| All (with readings) | 3136 | 49.2% | 47–51% | +$7,657.45 | +$2.44 |
| KEPT by the filter | 2834 | 50.0% | 48–52% | +$7,621.76 | +$2.69 |
| BLOCKED by the filter | 302 | 41.7% | 36–47% | +$35.69 | +$0.12 |
Win rate kept vs blocked: +8.3 points. The blocked trades made +$35.69 in total.
SHORT: Breadth under 50% up [breadth_24h_pct < 50]
| Group | Trades | Win rate | 95% range | Net P&L | Avg P&L |
|---|
| All (with readings) | 3136 | 49.2% | 47–51% | +$7,657.45 | +$2.44 |
| KEPT by the filter | 1931 | 43.6% | 41–46% | +$1,445.28 | +$0.75 |
| BLOCKED by the filter | 1205 | 58.2% | 55–61% | +$6,212.17 | +$5.16 |
Win rate kept vs blocked: -14.6 points. The blocked trades made +$6,212.17 in total.